Best Dog Toys for Border Collies

This post may contain affiliate links.

November 6, 2022 / Dog Toys / By: Krystine Therriault

Border Collies are known for being too smart for their own good!

Finding your intelligent Border Collie the best toy that keeps his attention for longer periods of time, is durable and keeps him mentally stimulated can pose to be a challenge for some owners.

If you are going through this same toy dilemma then take a look at ten of the best dog toys for Border Collies on the market today.

The 10 Best Border Collie Toys

1. Chuckit! Ultra Ball

Best Non-Toxic Dog Balls for Collies

The perfect dog ball for fetching that is durable, water resistant and easy to spot. They are the same size as a tennis ball but ten times sturdier.

As we said, this dog ball is no ordinary ball! Cleverly designed with high buoyancy and visibility the Chuckit! Ultra Ball promises to outplay and tire out your Border Collie.

Pair it with the with Chuckit! Ball Launcher and keep your arm from tiring out. This toy is a must staple in your dog toys arsenal

2. Chuckit! Flying Squirrel

Best Frisbee Dog Toy for Collies

Another clever design dog toy from Chuckit! and perfect for Border Collies. This is an excellent frisbee mainly due to its aerodynamic design. Its shape makes it very easy to throw, easy for your Collie to pick up, flows in water and its corners glow in the dark. 

Between the clever colors used and glowing corners, your Collie will never have a problem to find it unlike your regular frisbee.

Don't underestimate its flying capability or its durability - the Flying Squirrel is your go to toy for outdoor playing.

3. KONG Wobbler Treat Dispensing Dog Toy

Best Made in the USA Dog Toy

The Kong Wobbler Dog Toy aka the Kong Classic is simply the best dog toy for your arsenal. If you're looking to keep dogs busy and excited for hours while you are away from home, this toy won't let you down.

Stuff it with the right treats or freeze it or as a toy on it's own. Durability is not an issue and will remain fully intact for many years to come.

Use the Wobbler as an alternative to a dog bowl and to help extend mealtime and exercise your fur-kid.  Overall a great sturdy and safe toy that helps address unwanted behavioral issues like destructive chewing or excessive barking from boredom or separation anxiety.

4. Multipet Duckworth Webster Plush Filled Dog Toy

Best Border Collie Puppy Toy

You can't skip quality plush dog toys and this one from Multipet is a comforting toy your Border Collie puppy will adore.

It's large, has a squeaker to keep your pup entertained and it's plush enough for cuddling up next to during the night for comfort.

This soft duck toy with squeakers comes in various bright colors and measures 13-inches in length and 4-inches wide.

The duck is sturdy and some pet parents report the squeaker isn't an overly obnoxious one..... you'll be glad to hear.  An inexpensive loved dog toy by many and something different for your Collie to try.  

5. WestPaw Zogoflex Zisc

Best Toy for High Energy Collies

On par with the Chuckit toys, the WestPaw fribsee is another great aerodynamic toss and retrieve toy that lasts literally forever.

Not to be used as a tug or chew toy, the Heliflight will fly even during the most windiest days. This 8" toss and retrieve toy is made from a soft and flexible material which means it will be easy on your pup's teeth and gums but is super sturdy.

Able to withstand a pitbull's jaw durability is not an issue.

This clever piece of canine engineering toy flies long distances, it's easy to throw, floats in water and it's easy to spot since it's bright orange color. It's easy to see why owners refer to it as the best dog frisbee.

6. Jolly Pets Tug-n-Toss - Heavy Duty Chew Ball w/ Handle

Best Durable Tug Toy for Collies

This fetch and retrieve toy is a must for high energy Border Collies.

The handle makes it easy for your dog to carry and toss or for you to pick up and throw. It has a tough exterior but still bounces. 

This is the perfect toy for Collies who love running around and play fetch or tug-of-war for the perfect bonding experience.

It comes in four different sizes 4.5", 6", 8", 10", however we recommend either the 6 or 8-inch for your Collie.

7. KONG Extreme Goodie Bone Dog Toy 

Best Toy for Aggressive Chewers

A durable and safe toy for hard core aggressive chewers.

Stuff the ends of the bone with treats. The special "goodie grippers" hold it in place securely keeping your Border Collie intrigued and entertained for hours. It's available in three size.

We recommend the large size bone for your Border Collie. The bone is roughly around 8.5" long and is made of strong rubber. A favorite among hard core chewers.

8. Antler Man® Premium Deer Antler Pieces

Best Natural Chew Toys

If your Border Collie enjoys chewing then these safe and natural dog chews are your best distractions.

If you don't want your Collie to chew on your shoes, let them gnaw at these deer antlers instead.

These chews will also benefit your dog's health since deer antlers are a natural source of Calcium, Glucosamine, Iron & Potassium.

The antlers are roughly the size of a Coke can and customer ratings give it five stars for the best dog chews.

9. Nina Ottosson DogCasino Interactive Game (Advanced Level)

Best Puzzle Toy for Border Collies

Created by a Swedish dog trainer, DogCasino interactive dog puzzle will provide the mental stimulation high energy breeds like Border Collies need.

This durable Level 3 interactive dog toy will help your Collie interested for long periods of time. Your pup looks for treats by sliding out the trays. It's easy to keep clean since it's dishwasher safe. These can also be used at feedtime to help slow down your dog's eating.

If you own a Braniac like a Collie, this a great fun puzzle dog toy to give them the necessary mental stimulation they so much need.

Here Shiba Inu Saki demonstrates how to use the Dog Casino dog toy.

10. Buster Food Cube

Best Treat Food Puzzle for Border Collies

Finally, yet another sturdy and durable dog toy for your arsenal. You can never have enough durable toys! The OurPets' Buster Food Cube Dog Toy is made from hard plastic and can be stuffed with your pup's dog food or favorite dog treat. You can safely leave this toy with your Collie while you're away as he is guaranteed to be 100% distracted with the challenge and hours of entertainment this toy brings.

Three year old Border Collie ~Sai~ demonstrates how to use Buster Cube.

These are our recommendations for the top rated durable dog toys suitable for Border Collies based on our research and why we love them.

This next section deals with how to best keep Collies entertained, the games to play to keep them challenged and the toys to avoid buying.

A Quick Look at Your Border Collie's Genetic Predispositions

As previously alluded to Border Collies are intelligent, obedient dogs and are a great addition for families with children or active singles.

They are a medium sized breed that ranges from 27 to 45 pounds and do best in houses with yards and rural areas where they have a space to run around and play.

Due to their past as herding dogs, Border Collies are sometimes known for trying to herd family members.

Border Collies are known for being the ‘workaholics’ of the dog world. They are historically from the British Isles, where they were bred as herding dogs who didn’t need to bite or bark to get results.

Because of their breeding, Collies are energetic and eager to learn, and they need to be kept busy with tasks that require their attention and make them feel needed.

When training this breed, owners must assert their dominance and be patient. With the right persistence, treats and playtime worked into training sessions, Collies can be very clever and obedient. They love to perform tricks for an audience and have unique personalities.

How Do Border Collies Like To Play?

There is nothing sadder than seeing a hyped up Collie bored - she'll just end up running around your apartment or house to expend her energy levels. Or worse still end up acting out and start behaving aggressively

Border Collies are an energetic and playful breed that love to run, walk, swim, hike, fetch, and do pretty much every other fun activity you can think of! Drop by and read our hiking, camping or backpacking with your dog resource guide for more tips and ideas along with our blog post on dog-kayaking.

Since they are such intelligent dogs, keep them busy with toys that can hold their interest while you are away, like interactive toys and puzzles.

Keep only a few toys out at a time and rotate them around to keep their novelty since Border Collies get bored easily playing with the same toy. 

This breed has a long history of being working dogs, so keeping a Border Collie busy with tasks around the house is a great, natural way to make this breed feel like an important member of the family.

Owners have had their BC's successfully trained to fetch the mail, pick items from the fridge, put toys away, bring different items like the TV remote, and any other such similar housekeeping tasks

Games You Can Play With Your Collie to Manage their Energy Levels

As a breed known for herding, Border Collies can handle high energy games like Flyball, which combines racing and agility with retrieving a ball.

Owners with a big back yard can do some agility and obedience training with their Border Collies at home, using household items like hula hoops for their pets to jump through.

Both flyball and agility training are guaranteed to have your Border Collie tire out. 

Here is a quick 30 second video you will enjoy of an owner and his active and playful Border Collie ~Pepe~ doing agility training in his own backyard. 

While a filled Kong will keep your Collie occupied for at least an hour, another way to keep her from acting out due to boredom is to hide treats around your home for her to find and give her something to do. 

Interactive toys are your best friend while you are away from home. This will help keep your pup occupied for hours figuring out how to get a treat out. On the plus, these will also help tire her out mentally. 

Trick training is another successful method of keeping this workaholic breed entertained. Train your Collie to sit, lay down, shake, high five and roll over. 

Rollerblading, tugs games, running, hill-waking are all great methods to exercise your Border Collie alongside with you. 

Avoid Cheap Toys with Small Parts

Border Collies are sometimes known for destructive chewing when they are bored or don’t have healthy outlets like chew toys around the house.

This can rule out soft plush dog toys. Cheaper dog toys that are easy for dogs to tear apart can pose a choking hazard if they have small parts like a squeaker inside.

So stick with brands you know that you can trust and have great customer feedback to back this up.

In Summary

Border Collies are great dogs for active families that love spending time outdoors enjoy playing with their dog and keeping him busy.

Border Collies are famous working dogs, so giving them a chance to use their intelligence to get tasks done is crucial to keeping this breed happy.

Buying toys for a Border Collie is easy since they are quite playful, but owners should look for safe, durable toys that will keep their pets interested for long periods at a time. You won’t go wrong with any of these dog toy options.


What are your own experiences with dog toys and tips for keeping Border Collies entertained? Share your tips below and please don’t forget to share with us if you found this content useful!


Krystine Therriault

Krystine Therriault is an accomplished writer. With a passion for all creatures cute and furry, Krystine's life has been touched by many beloved dogs over the years. She is also a loving mother of two boys and an avid yogi.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}


Maltese dog licking its lips.

The 5 Best Lick Mats for Dogs: Enrich and Calm Your Doggo!

A puppy licking and playing with a Frozen black KONG dog toy

The 5 Best Fill and Freeze Dog Toys: Chill and Enrich Your Pup!

Soothing toys for anxious puppies

Best Heartbeat Toys For a Puppy: Night Time Toy!

Global Site Tag